Comparison of WinMOD and SIMIT for virtual commissioning of an automotive production line

Abstract

This study presents a comparative evaluation of two virtual commissioning software tools: SIMIT and WinMOD, explaining their functionalities and potential boundaries within existing industrial processes. A hands-on test project was carried out using SIMIT to comprehend the software's technical specifications as well as the broader concept of Virtual Commissioning (VC). This practical approach provided the insights and knowledge needed to formulate appropriate queries during the following interviews. Experienced engineers, each proficient in one of the software, were interviewed to gain insight about the important factors for transitioning between the software, as well as their benefits and limitations. In the software transition process, the study emphasizes the importance of toolkits, efficient workflow management, and cost considerations. The decision between SIMIT and WinMOD was based on industry-specific requirements, compatibility with existing systems, and the ability of each software to meet organizational needs. The findings contribute significantly to the ongoing discussion on digital transformation and automation in the industrial sector, laying the groundwork for future research to optimize the use of these technologies. Further research is recommended to delve deeper into each software's capabilities, efficient workflow designs, and the impact of transitioning from one software to another, supplementing the decision-making process for organizations contemplating a software transition